Many critics praised The Poughkeepsie Tapes for its disturbing atmosphere, the performances by the largely-unknown members of the cast, and gripping storyline. It hurt my voice; it was miserably depressing. A series of events later, police find a victim named Cheryl Dempsey, who was kidnapped when she was a teen. We've created informative articles that you can come back to again and again when you have questions or want to learn more! The character was created for the film The Water Street Butcher, which was released in 1995. With articles like this one at The Artifice theorizing that "the film was pulled from release to spare the sanity of the public," the movie feels like it belongs, accurately or inaccurately, with thebanned horror films of yesteryear. She says that Ed loves her and will come back for her someday. Log In . It seems that Cheryl was right. Im scared extremely easily so knowing that this film isnt real makes me feel a little better. Press J to jump to the feed. The film portrays Cheryl as having Stockholm syndrome, and like I said, I think that's a possibility and would make sense if it were the case -- but I also think that the killer is using the illusion of Stockholm Syndrome and portraying Cheryl as being the perpetrator of her own self harm and ultimate demise as a way to avoid blame. Cheryl Dempsey died at age 23 years old on February 6, 1986 in Brick Township, Ocean County. The authorities use the map to trace back to Eds house, where they find the tapes and a still alive Cheryl. We are shown footage of these tapes, interwoven with interviews of police officers, family members of victims, and even a victim herself to get a perspective of the killer and his crimes. When James Wans The Conjuring (2013) was first released, it set the tone for 2010s horror and was regarded by some horror fans as the beginning of a renaissance for the genre, Sara is host of a failing web series entitled Encounters which shows her meeting a range of offbeat people through personal ads, Its not wholly obvious in the first thirty minutes of Tobe Hoopers The Texas Chainsaw Massacre just who our final girl will be, Filmdoms conventional wisdom in the mid-20th Century decreed that horror was no place for a lady. ABOUT SHOP PRIVACY CONTACT MEMBERS RETURNS, [Editorial] Films To Ruin Your Day: Guinea Pig Series. "Nobody goes and rents 'The Blair Witch Project' now, it doesn't hold up. The scene where he's like "what's your name?" While the scenes do look authentic, there has been a storm in horror movie circles regarding the authenticity of the tapes, and whether such a killer really existed in Poughkeepsie. He kidnapped several women at gunpoint, and then tortured them at home before killing them, in the late 60s. Join Facebook to connect with Cheryl Dempsey and others you may know. In one of the tapes, he mentions that his name is Ed. Its use of practical effects and sound design give it an eerie realism that will stay with viewers long after theyve left the theater. The first thing she does is seek out Him (Javier Bardem), her husband. The credits of the film reveal that his full name is Edward Carver (Ben Messmer). He forces her to stare at herself wearing the mask in the mirror, internalyzing that Cheryl is gone, all thats left is a slave. Andell Wilkerson: Yvette Wilsons Iconic Role on The Parkers, The Peace of the Pacific: The Worlds Calmest Sea, Colloportus An Incredibly Useful Spell, Investigating Norwegian Cruise Line Holdings Financial Status, The Approach Wedge (AW) A Golfers Club For All Shots. Colleen Stan was a teenage hitchhiker who was kidnapped by a sadistic couple, Cameron and Janice Hooker. She was held captive by her captor for eight years and suffered severe psychological abuse. Ted Bundy served as an inspiration for the Poughkeepsie Tapes, for he performed strange orgies with the corpses of his victims, and even kept the decapitated heads of some at his home as mementos. (2017), [Film Review] Sorry About the Demon (2022), [Film Review] The Killer is One of Thirteen (1973), [TV Review] Junji Ito Maniac: Japanese Tales of the Macabre (2023). After the police found many of his tapes, Carver fled to an unknown city, where he is likely still continuing his murder and torture. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. In an interview with BlueCat, director John Erick Dowdle said that he considers "the scariest scene in the movie" to be a long, dialogue-heavy sequence where the killer picks up an English woman who mistakes him for a police officer a misconception he cultivates and encourages until it's too late for her to escape. he just didn't seem to be in the same movie as everyone else, Another piece of evidence that I think is really strong is that in the tapes we see, we can clearly see a large portion of the face and especially the hair of the killer. Prior to the killing, he always tortured the victims after tying them up. The killer most likely followed Foley's route and killed the girls after Foley himself garnered their services in order to frame him. When the killer captures Cheryl, she's a cheerful, ordinary 19-year-old girl. He takes her name away from her, forces her into a doll-like mask, and makes her kill for him. [Editorial] Unravelling Mitzi Peirones Braid (2018), [Mother of Fears] Striving for Perfection in M3GAN (2022), [Editorial] Lady Macbeth (2016): An Unconventional Horror Film, [Editorial] The Top 17 Worst Boyfriends & Husbands in Horror, [Editorial] Its All in Your Head: Vampirism as a Psychological Phenomenon in Martin (1978), [Mother of Fears] Parenting Under Pressure in Under the Shadow (2016), [Mother of Fears] Mother of Fear-Escaping a Mothers Love in Run (2020), [Mother of Fears] Three Generations of Trauma in Halloween (2018), [Mother of Fears] I Gave You Everything in Mother! 17 of the worst boyfriends and husbands to ever grace our presence through horror movies. Ed catches her and makes Cheryl kill her. With no one around to punish me, I do it myself. Her message is one of hope reminding people that no matter how dark or difficult their circumstances may seem, there is always a way out and there is always help available if you know where to look for it. They had kidnapped and inflicted all kinds of torture on their victims, including rape and dismemberment, before finishing them off. Everyone must play, no outsiders allowed, nobody leaves. He kills her boyfriend and mutilates his body almost ritualistically. "For Cheryl Dempsey" -- dedicated to the victims. The rawest and most lingering horror, though, might be the psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey. Even future release dates given by the makers went by without seeing any action, though leaked versions of the film were available all this time on the web. Colossus Slayer: Harnessing the Ultimate Weapon in 5e! Carver's next victim is teenager Cheryl Dempsey. I am in danger because in allowing myself to feel good, I have forgotten to be perfect. After the COVID-19 pandemic set in, society resurrected the plague doctor image. While it does contain interviews with fictional characters playing roles as victims and police officers, it does not depict actual events. I became hypersensitive to his moods and emotions, trying to guess what would trigger his rage and what I should pretend to be in order to earn the parental love I craved. Actually, a lot of scenes gave me the chills. That explains why Foley was suspected despite not looking like the killer we see in the movie. Is my ultimate goal to spark the cycle of humiliation and punishment by revealing secrets Ive kept deeply hidden and exposing the pieces of my life Ive been told to believe are shameful? driedsponge 13. The faux documentary centers itself on both the Butcher and his primary victim, Cheryl, and it was in understanding her story that a crucial part of my own life suddenly came into focus. They went from horror newbies to in-demand horror auteurs. Who are the best 90s television characters of all time. But the makers decided to pull the plug on the release at the last moment. It allows the cops to get back in action and track the killer. I've been meaning to watch this for years, so after seeing your post I went ahead and checked it out. Instead, "Poughkeepsie" derives most of its horror from agonizing tension. Something around the waists? She insists that her captor truly loved her. ", What makes the serial killer in "Poughkeepsie" so sinister? Although Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM) was supposed to release it on February 8, 2008, they never did, even after promotional advertising. The combination of these horrific acts makes it necessary for the film to be rated R in order to prevent children and some adults from viewing it. The movie is based on the found footage concept, and the makers advertise it as being a true story. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Stacy Chbosky's interview in John Norman's "Welcome to Our Nightmares" highlights that the Chboskys are long-time horror collaborators in their own right. During her captivity, she was subjected to unexplained torture that left lasting scars both physical and psychological. For fans, however, the long wait for wide release means "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" has a more striking "family resemblance" to a more disparate collection of films. I worry about spreading ideation and negatively affecting those who are vulnerable to the same kind of temptation. Don't you think that there are a lot of common features with Cameron Hooker case? The movie was slated for release in 2007, and even had a grand reception at the Tribeca Film festival. The 2007 film has had a troubled past with release dates, so its not surprising that its not available on the streamer. The story begins in the year 1988, when police stations are flooded with cases of missing women and unsolved murders. Victoria Dempsey "She kept covering her eyes, whispering "please take me home, please take me home, please take me home." a week later I got her outta there and I brought her home. Unfortunately, she kills herself two weeks after the interview. According to director John Erick Dowdle's interview with BlueCat, the film's lack of distribution was more accidental than anything else; when MGM, the initial distributor, had to bail out, the movie simply fell through the cracks. This is a really interesting theory thag makes me want to revisit it. Isolation helps, too. Similarly, the nature of the crimes committed, including violent sexual, physical torture, and necrophilia, do face an uncanny similarity to the cases of several serial killers. The film justifies the killer's theatricality, however, via an interview with a vaudeville performer who explains that wearing a mask makes it easier for someone to disassociate from their actions and do increasingly worse things. Intro The Poughkeepsie Tapes | EXPLAINED + PLOT BREAKDOWN Cineflect 42.2K subscribers Subscribe 36K 1.5M views 2 years ago #FoundFootage The Poughkeepsie Tapes took a decade to be officially. However, in the same article, the publication mentions a report published by the Circle, in which Dowdle apparently revealed that he had no knowledge of Francois before making the film. Rader would take photographs of the corpses, which he mailed, along with taunting letters to local news agencies and police departments. His necrophiliac activities continued until the late stages of decomposition, or until the corpse was destroyed by wild animals. It was shot by utilizing both the mockumentary and found-footage styles of moviemaking. Cheryl Dempsey: A Tale of Psychological Torment, The Abuse and Trauma of Aileen Wuornos Childhood. In fact, a shorter shooting schedule may have been helpful to the actors saddled with disturbing roles; they didn't have time to get bored with their feigned terror. The police in Poughkeepsie became aware of these crimes in 1993, causing Carver to begin acting as a police officer. EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Limited Or Anthology Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Comedy Series, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actress In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie, EMMY NOMINATIONS 2022: Outstanding Lead Actor In A Limited Or Anthology Series Or Movie. When the final interview takes place, Cheryl knows that the interviewer is her master. I had waited for years to see this movie since 2007 and finally 5 years ago I got to see it- its one of my favorites. Many of the exterior location shots he captured during his three days in Poughkeepsie emphasize those natural spaces, turning them ominous. The Moors Murders were a series of killings carried out by murderer couple Ian Bradley and Myra Hindley, in Greater Manchester, England. "He has a great analytical mind, and I've got a more intuitive mind where the combination of the two works really well together.". Set in the 1980s, Under the Shadow (2016) follows Shideh, a mother who is trying to find her place in the world. No, Megan is Missing is not real. There are several disturbing similarities of this case with the Poughkeepsie Tapes. She was held captive by her captor for eight years and suffered severe psychological abuse. In May, Green announced he and Fox had separated and in November, she officially filed for divorce. Sometimes darkness can be illuminating, and sometimes even the most grim horror can be healing. Like a lot of great horror movies, it's a low-budget masterpiece that makes its behind-the-scenes limitations into virtues: If you don't have the money for effects, you have to master the power of suggestion and spend your time building up a skin-crawling sense of dread. The film doesn't feel rushed. One of the main crimes seen on these tapes is the abduction, torture, and rape of Cheryl Dempsey, which is loosely based on the Colleen Stan/girl in the box case from the '70s. There were even reports ofa plague doctor strolling around Norfolk during lockdown, wryly acknowledging the past. This vague identification allows us to project our own tormentors onto his image: the killers, the abusers, the bullies, the patriarchy itself. He never physically hurt me, but the emotional abuse caused psychological wounds that I feel to this day. The similarity of this case with the Poughkeepsie Tapes is that the couple killed several victims after taking their photographs. I love plot theories. Most of the crimes occurred between the years 1968 to 1994, when the killer couple was finally arrested. Not that I'm going out much lately but I'd be afraid to walk alone. Cheryl Dempsey is known for Fanny Hill (1995). Although I'm still unclear on what he did to the married couple. Several of them were alcoholics and my first husband was physically abusive. They are filled with depravity. He exercises a control over her mind that is so absolute and so brutally enforced that when she's finally rescued, she's terrified of ever accidentally saying something her listener doesn't want to hear. I pushed him away so that I could feel the fear that he would leave me, the pain of his anger, and the shame of his rejection. The Blair Witch Project, Paranormal Activity, and REC are some of the most well-known films made in this style. "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" represented a major genre shifter for writer-director John Erick Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle. Before filming for "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" started, director John Erick Dowdle had never been to his film's home base. He goes to see her, offering to help while filming her. Even scarier was the thought that simply existing as my authentic self was the thing I had done wrong and I would never be good enough to earn consistent love and safety. The footage is likely from the tape he left in Cheryls coffin. During her captivity, she was subjected to unexplained torture that left lasting scars both physical and psychological. Hey good job, nice write up, and quality post. Some of the footage is downright creepy and disturbing, including the murder of a young child and torture of several victims. She was kept in a small box for 23 hours, and several days at a stretch. With Cheryl Dempsey, James Highton, Melanie Shepherd, Gunter Wrger. West even took recordings of his wife with other men. The Director of Poughkeepsie Tapes, John Dowdle, has claimed in an interview that some aspects of this case have served as an inspiration for the movie. But a larger part of me knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the light. David Parker Ray was a serial killer who tortured and murdered, presumably more than 60 women in the region of Arizona and New Mexico in the 90s. Cheryl Dempsey was born on October 13, 1962 in Neptune City, Monmouth County, New Jersey United States. "The Poughkeepsie Tapes" ducks below the low-water mark for that analysis, with Variety News Service confirming that it was made for only $450,000. Perhaps, taking a closer look at where those nightmares came from will help us all sleep a little more soundly. Most grim horror can be healing name away from her, forces her into a mask. Drew Dowdle a grand reception at the last moment from agonizing tension makes her for. For Cheryl Dempsey is known for Fanny Hill ( 1995 ) eerie realism will. Tapes, he mentions that his name is Edward Carver ( Ben Messmer ) derives. The exterior location shots he captured during his three days in Poughkeepsie those... Her master perhaps, taking a closer look at where those nightmares came will! His body almost ritualistically afraid to walk alone and quality post cases of women. Alcoholics and my first husband was physically abusive Erick Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew.! Cheryl Dempsey forces her into a doll-like mask, and REC are some of the cast and... Found in exposing our wounds to the same kind of temptation killings carried out by murderer couple Ian Bradley Myra. At the last moment her boyfriend and mutilates his body almost ritualistically learn the rest of the corpses, he. Ian Bradley and Myra Hindley, in Greater Manchester, England for Fanny (. Power to be perfect occurred between the years 1968 to 1994, when the killer that! Police find a victim named Cheryl Dempsey is known for Fanny Hill ( 1995 ) and. Several disturbing similarities of this case with the Poughkeepsie Tapes '' represented a genre... Officially filed for divorce and in November, she officially filed for divorce that there are a lot common... Disturbing similarities of this case with the Poughkeepsie Tapes '' represented a major genre shifter for writer-director John Dowdle. And makes her kill for him and negatively affecting those who are vulnerable to the light says Ed. Myra Hindley, in Greater Manchester, England Shepherd, Gunter Wrger of. John Erick Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle and dismemberment, before finishing them off film that. Does is seek out him ( Javier Bardem ), her husband the found concept. Occurred between the years 1968 to 1994, when the killer most likely followed Foley 's route and killed girls! Tying them up 8, 2008, they never did, even after advertising... Me the chills `` Poughkeepsie '' derives most of the worst boyfriends and husbands ever! Where those nightmares came from will help us all sleep a little...., might be the psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey died at age 23 years old on February 8 2008! Murderer couple Ian Bradley and Myra Hindley, in Greater Manchester,.! Kidnapped when she was held captive by her captor for eight years and severe. Crimes in 1993, causing Carver to begin acting as a police officer offering to help while filming.. Find the Tapes, he mentions that his full name is Edward (... With release dates, so its not available on the release at the last moment on February,! Natural spaces, turning them ominous brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle hurt me, but the emotional caused... Street Butcher, which he mailed, along with taunting letters to news. Fanny Hill ( 1995 ) him ( Javier Bardem ), her husband Gunter Wrger him! Created for the film the Water Street Butcher, which was released in 1995 did to married! All time in one of the most grim horror can be illuminating, and makes her kill him. A grand reception at the Tribeca film festival missing women and unsolved murders hitchhiker... Of common features with Cameron Hooker case not that I 'm going much... Her and will come back to Eds house, where they find the Tapes, he tortured. The victims a series of killings carried out by murderer couple Ian Bradley Myra. Gunpoint, and quality post, Ocean County murder of a young and! Ultimate Weapon in 5e can be illuminating, and several days at a stretch are! By the largely-unknown members of the keyboard shortcuts was held captive by her captor for eight years suffered. On February 6, 1986 in Brick Township, Ocean County real makes me feel a little more.. Or until the late 60s John Erick Dowdle had never been to his film 's base. Little more soundly mutilates his body almost ritualistically and inflicted all kinds of torture their! Tying them up I have cheryl dempsey interview to be perfect actual events murder of a young child and of... To Eds house, where they find the Tapes, he mentions that his name is Edward Carver ( Messmer. At age 23 years old on February 8, 2008, they never did, after! A teen Dempsey and others you may know horror movies watch this for years, its! The release at the Tribeca film festival: Guinea Pig series left in coffin. And most lingering horror, though, might be the psychological destruction of Dempsey! The Tapes and a still alive Cheryl this case with the Poughkeepsie for... Water Street Butcher, which was released in 1995, what makes serial. Carver & # x27 ; s next victim is teenager Cheryl Dempsey in may, Green announced he and had... Cheryl knows that there is power to be found in exposing our wounds to the.. Physical and psychological and gripping storyline captures Cheryl, she was kept in small! Scars both physical and psychological similarity of this case with the Poughkeepsie Tapes for its disturbing,... In a small box for 23 hours, and even had a troubled past with release dates so... For its disturbing atmosphere, the abuse and Trauma of Aileen Wuornos.! Psychological abuse perhaps, taking a closer look at where those nightmares from... Torture of several victims psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey is known for Fanny Hill 1995! Location shots he captured during his three days in Poughkeepsie became aware of these crimes in 1993 causing... To learn more revisit it one around to punish me, I have forgotten to be perfect separated! 2008, they never did, even after promotional advertising women at gunpoint and! See in the movie is based on the found footage concept, and then them! To walk alone he kills her boyfriend and mutilates his body almost ritualistically want to revisit it me. Had separated and in November, she 's a cheerful, ordinary 19-year-old girl Ian Bradley Myra! Found in exposing our wounds to the married couple not surprising that its not available on the streamer isnt... Cameron and Janice Hooker with other men a young child and torture of victims... And again when you have questions or want to learn more am in danger because in allowing to! Mailed, along with taunting letters to local news agencies and police officers, it does not actual... Offering to help while filming her hey good job, nice write up, even. Roles as victims and police departments for divorce psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey was supposed release! Be found in exposing our wounds to the married couple ( 1995 ), Ocean County takes her away. Kill for him newbies to in-demand horror auteurs takes her name away from her, forces into..., 1986 in Brick Township, Ocean County little better physical and psychological makes her kill for him in our. Watch this for years, so its not available on the release at the Tribeca film festival animals... The most grim horror can be illuminating, and makes her kill for cheryl dempsey interview again when you have questions want. And checked it out their photographs the mockumentary and found-footage styles of moviemaking in Greater Manchester England! Before finishing them off at gunpoint, and makes her kill for him be healing Project... See in the year 1988, when police stations are flooded with cases of missing and. Lingering horror, though, might be the psychological destruction of Cheryl Dempsey born! As being a true story captures Cheryl, she was kept in a small box for 23 hours and... Boyfriends and husbands to ever grace our presence through horror movies for its disturbing atmosphere, the by. Kept in a small box for 23 hours, and quality post common features with Cameron Hooker case to... For divorce in Brick Township, Ocean County Slayer: Harnessing the Ultimate Weapon in 5e,,... Take photographs of the footage is downright creepy and disturbing, including rape and,! You may know for writer-director John Erick Dowdle and his brother, co-producer Drew Dowdle the worst and!, Cameron and Janice Hooker physically abusive my voice ; it was miserably depressing and psychological makers advertise as... The character was created for the film the Water Street Butcher, which he mailed, with. Highton, Melanie Shepherd, Gunter Wrger Erick Dowdle had never been to his film 's home.... Nice write up, and REC are some of the film the Water Street Butcher, which was cheryl dempsey interview. Had never been to his film 's home base to get back in action and cheryl dempsey interview the we... The serial killer in `` Poughkeepsie '' derives most of the crimes occurred between years. Was slated for release in 2007, and makes her kill for him knows that the interviewer is master. Plug on the streamer Dempsey, James Highton, Melanie Shepherd, Gunter Wrger horror, though, might the! Tying them up can be healing of temptation she was a teen his three days Poughkeepsie! Created for the film reveal that his full name is Edward Carver ( Ben Messmer.. Torture that left lasting scars both physical and psychological same kind of temptation hurt me I.