Democrats blamed Republican-appointed regulators for failing to prepare the grid for disasters. The trend of population shifts from Democratically dominated "blue" states to Republican-controlled "red" states only accelerated in the COVID-era of the past 2 years, according to census data and other information from companies like U-Haul. Rev. In both California and New York, 1-in-5 Democratic registered voters stated that the quality of life has worsened at a time when most of their state and federal representatives are Democrats. One of the ladies that I work with up at Walmart, I talked to her last week and I asked her, Hey, did you ever get your coronavirus shot yet? Oh, no. But although Arizona is blue for now, Volgy isn't committed to that. Voters seem to be fine with the status quo, said Drew Landry, assistant professor of government at South Plains College in Levelland, west of Lubbock. Florida added one seat, and Texas added two. Podhorzer defines modern red and blue America as the states in which each party has usually held unified control of the governorship and state legislature in recent years. In California, for all its dissatisfied people, only 2% had taken all four actions. They cant make me take that vaccine, he said, quoting her. A 13-year-old girl named Meilin turns into a giant red panda whenever she gets too excited. Rather than just protecting slavery within their borders, the Southern states sought to control federal policy to impose their vision across more of the nation, including, potentially, to the point of overriding the prohibitions against slavery in the free states. We also asked Republican respondents to choose head-to-head between DeSantis and Trump. We should've done this a long time ago, but my Democrat opponents have failed to come through for Oregon families. Only 19%of Texas voters believe there is frequent voter fraud, yet lawmakers cemented Texas status as thehardestplace to vote in the country by restricting early voting options and empowering partisan poll watchers. . #orpol pic.twitter.com/Tdw0acrwj0, Christine Drazan (@ChristineDrazan) August 9, 2022. Georgia, once a strongly Republican state, has turned blue. Period.. ), Our survey asked respondents across the nation to register their early preferences for the 2024 presidential race. (April 26), Get a digest of our takes on current events every day, Democrats still face daunting historical odds, voted Democratic only once in a presidential election since 1948, not occupied both U.S. Senate seats since 1952, Your California Privacy Rights/Privacy Policy. Like other analysts who study democracy, he views the Trump faction that now dominates the Republican Partywhat he terms the MAGA movementas the U.S. equivalent to the authoritarian parties in places such as Hungary and Venezuela. It's official: Florida is a red state The former swing state is now a lost cause for Democrats. Its our 10th year participating in Amplify, and to celebrate, weve got $15,000 in matching funds from four generous Tribune supporters. Mostly, Republicans do well in rural areas, Democrats do well in the cities, and the suburbs are mixed but are more Republican. The big blue states of California and New York actually lost people over the last decade, meaning more people moved out than moved in. That can't be good," Chishti said. Spencer drew only 18 percent of the vote. I was seeing some very, very close numbers before a lot of the rural counties reported [election returns], and once they did, it just blew the door open for Abbott and [Lt. Gov. Spencer, who has been involved in Democratic politics since the early 1990s, said his party affiliation has not been a helpful calling card for him in his community. As the nation has sorted itself into red and blue territory, places where Democrats once were competitive in state races have become more solidly Republican. Texas40 electoral votes are on the table. . JB Pritzkers successful 2018 campaign, the number of Illinois counties voting Democratic got smaller and smaller during a 20-year period. Some of the more notable states on the list are California, New York, Illinois, and Washington, DC. To respond to a column, submit a comment to letters@usatoday.com. "It would be smart for people heading into the 2022 campaign to level with their . To put the states seismic political weight into perspective, based on thecurrent electoral map, Democrats could loseArizona,Florida,Michigan,Ohio,Pennsylvaniaand Wisconsin and still take the White House if they won Texas. Poshard, of downstate Marion, won 43 counties during his bid for governor but lost to Republican George Ryan by less than 4 percentage points. Beyond determining who will occupy governors offices, these contests will shape our nations direction in the coming years. The biggest news is that the exodus from progressive-led states hasn't slowed . Nationally and in Illinois, thats concerning, Jacobson said. Life expectancy is nearly three years greater in the blue (80.1 years) than the red (77.4) states. If you put together the city and the suburbs, thats a winning combination for any candidate. On the ground, John Spencer sees everything exactly as Poshard lays out. The hardening difference between red and blue, Podhorzer maintains, empowers the 10 purple states (if you include Arizona and Georgia) to decide which of the two superpower nations values, Blue or Red, will prevail in presidential and congressional elections. While interesting for a variety of reasons, match-ups including Biden or Trump do not cause respondents to consider the possibility of a governor introducing a blue or red state model to the nation as a whole. Meanwhile, California, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts, and New Jersey rounded out the bottom of the list. andrew.sinclair@claremontmckenna.edu PROVIDENCE, R.I. Republicans are pressing their advantage deep into Democratic territory in the closing stretch of the 2022 campaign, competing for an abundance of House seats amid growing. More of the potential movers are motivated by what we categorized as personal reasons. This comes after Donald Trump won Georgia by six points in 2016. The responses varied by party, with greater percentages of Republicans than Democrats in both red and blue states expressing this view. Bailey is one of three downstate Republicans to publicly declare their intentions to take on Pritzker next year. Over the past year, however, many of our Chicago teams have asked to relocate to Miami, New York, and our other offices around the world.. And one crucial element of that, he argues, is the return of what he calls one-party rule in the red nation.. Well, I found out this morning, shes on a ventilator., When asked if he knows anyone who has succumbed to the illness, Spencer said, Oh yeah, I know a lot of people thats died from COVID.. While two points might not seem like much, that tiny difference tells a compelling story. In Texas and Florida, independents are marginally adding to the incumbents lead, whereas in California and New York, disapproval from independents is not enough to overcome the Democrats large numerical advantages. pandemic The data for this survey comes from the CMC-Rose Institute Fall 2022 Poll. Moreover, some Democrats reported a worsening financial situation and others a worsening quality of life; in California, for example, 1-in-3 Democrats thought that the quality of life was worse or that their personal financial situation was worse. They worked, tirelessly, so my brother and I could have opportunities they never had. All of this is fueling what Ive called the great divergence now under way between red and blue states. The survey design included a national sample of 1,000 registered voters and state oversamples of approximately equal sizes of registered voters in California, New York, Texas, and Florida, as well as in Pennsylvania (the subject of a separate report). In 2020, Democrat Joe Biden laid claim to just 14 Illinois counties. And red states across the Sun Belt rank among the nations fastest growing in population. Republicans are on a long winning streak in Florida, even if their victories have been by small . On any political map, Illinois is a reliable blue state that has elected Democratic governors four of the last five elections and last backed a Republican presidential candidate before Michael Jordan was winning championships in Chicago. And Donald Trump won the state by less than 6 percentage points in 2020. The Trump model, in other words, is more the South in 1850 than the South in 1950, more John Calhoun than Richard Russell. People do, and that accounts for why Democrats keep winning governors races in Illinois during the past quarter century despite not having a message that resonates throughout all 102 counties. Increasingly, Americans are also choosing to move to places that align with their political views. Max Abrahms (right), who teaches national security and terrorism courses, warns of labeling America's red-blue divide a civil war. Among Republicans, former President Trump is the most popular, with Florida Governor Ron DeSantis clearly the leading alternative. Pritzker did so while losing 86 out of Illinois 102 counties, but that showing amounted to an improvement for Democrats over previous elections. Most of the states are likely to stay red or blue after Tuesday, but a few key races are seen as toss-ups. A Republican from San Diego wrote, Taxes are too high in my state and the quality of life is getting worse. An independent from near Santa Barbara wrote more simply, CA is run by morons., The story is somewhat different in Texas and Florida. That doesnt mean that Americans are condemned to fight one another again as they did after the 1850s. A purple state is one in which voters' support for the Democratic Party, represented by the color blue, and the Republican Party, represented by the color red, is about equal. But Arizona is a blue state. They have moved to the left and to the right, respectively, since 1970, with. In any event, our purpose is not predictive. More than half of Republicans (58%) and Democrats (55%) said they thought about moving to a state where the government better reflects their political and policy values, while 69% of Democrats and 65% of Republicans considered moving . According to Gallup tracking, there were 15 stable blue states in 2017. Another issue of concern to the electorate in his area are vaccine mandates. By Brian Trusdell | I had a real good construction business going, but I seen a year ago that those days were over because Im a Democrat. Abbott began busing undocumented immigrants to other states last spring and has steered $4.4 billion toward his Operation Lone Star mission along the Texas-Mexico border moves that drove Democrats to accuse him of spending taxpayer money on political stunts. Instead, the poll seeks to highlight the levels of early support for Newsom compared to Hochul and DeSantis compared to Abbott, and to explore how DeSantis is faring as a potential successor (or challenger) to Trump. Countless More Americans Will Be Moving From Blue States To Red States In 2022 The Great Realignment By Michael Snyder. And those dividing lines were largely set at the nations founding, when slave states and free states forged an uneasy alliance to become one nation., Podhorzer isnt predicting another civil war, exactly. Republicans havent led the state of Oregon since 1982. Among likely voters: in California, 91% of Democrats are for Newsom; in New York, 89% of Democrats are for Hochul; in Texas, 95% of Republicans are for Abbott; and, in Florida, 97% of Republicans are for DeSantis. Because of that, he said, the labor vote in some areas downstate is trending Republican. Whitmer, Nikki Haleys Official 2024 Bid Harshly Criticized by DNC. Bailey is quick to invoke a biblical passage, Proverbs 28:2, to explain himself, his candidacy and where Illinois is at right now: When there is moral rot, a nations government topples easily, but wise and knowledgeable leaders bring stability.. Almost all of the red states have also passed stand your ground laws backed by the National Rifle Association, which provide a legal defense for those who use weapons against a perceived threat, while none of the blue states have done so. Our survey asked respondents to describe their interest in moving as follows: Regardless of whether you will move, if you had the opportunity, would you like to move to another state, or would you rather remain in your current state? It turns out that lots of people are interested in moving, with partisan views contributing to the response. It may be time to stop talking about red and blue America. This election thus provides voters in the four states an opportunity to judge not only their governors, but also the blue or red agendas they represent. Meanwhile, many Republicans described concerns about politics and policy, while very few Democrats did. . This virus has impacted all Americans." MORE: Trump's rebuke of CDC . As Jacobson, the journalist, found in his reporting for the University of Virginias Center for Politics, the trend is similar in presidential elections here. Because of this reality, these states can switch from supporting one party to the other, from election to election. The reluctance extends beyond those interested. Not only arethese laws antithetical tothe popular will of constituents, they also disproportionately harmpeople of color like my family. Biden's victory, and the matter in which he won, left many political pundits. These results are part of a larger survey project conducted by the CMC-Rose Institute Poll during the 2022 election cycle. The core question that Podhorzers analysis raises is how the United States will function with two sections that are moving so far apart. Democrats were more likely to consider moving to blue states (48%) than red states (25%) or swing states (27%). They just didnt vote, period.. study In each of the four states, our survey explored voter perceptions about how life was going with respect to your personal financial situation and the quality of life in your community. We asked: For each area, are things better or worse than they were two years ago?. Conversely, in each state, no more than 5% overall said they were financially much better off. The special examines how COVID-19 and the Draconian policies imposed by Democratic governors resulted in lawlessness, failed education, and botched public health policies. Democrat Joe Biden lost it by less than 3.5 . Holding incumbents accountable is complicated, though, in a system where policy authority is divided across multiple layers and branches of government, and partisanship seems to be more important than actually evaluating a governors performance. Our results are broadly consistent with the findings of other publicly available polls: among Democratic candidates, President Biden is ahead, but there is no clear back-up option. Weve done an awful lot for the entire state, but, especially I think working together with Republicans, we were able to create jobs. OREGON POLL: @ChristineDrazan 36%@TinaKotek 34%@senbetsyjohnson 19%9% undecidedhttps://t.co/Q4dZtymPg7 pic.twitter.com/NB2cIsLUfm, Emerson College Polling (@EmersonPolling) October 4, 2022. Reason to keep organizing, knocking doors, making phone calls, sending textsand persuading Texans from every corner of the state to vote. 9 of the 10 states with the most infections per capita have Republican governors. Its discouraging, and it causes the party apparatus and structure to just fall apart.. Since about 2008, Podhorzer calculates, the southern states at the heart of the red nation have again fallen further behind the blue nation in per capita income. Its a really stacked deck in these states because of this democratic backsliding, Grumbach said. If a red wave arrives in November, as many expect, it will likely wash ashore in landlocked Nevada, a state whose recent history of Democratic victories masks just how hard-fought those. In these. When Pritzker won the governorship, he reversed the volume of county losses by Democrats. There has never been a more urgent moment, however, for Democrats to organize and fight for transformative change in the Lone Star State. House Republicans are increasingly confident they can make unexpected inroads into some solidly Democratic congressional districts, including in some of the bluest states in the country: California, Connecticut, New York, Oregon and Rhode Island. But the party couldnt replicate it this time around, in spite of ORourke again leading the ticket as well as lingering anger over the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection by Trump supporters and a widely criticized law enforcement response to the May 24 school shooting in Uvalde. Andrew Sinclair, Ph.D. Drazan has thus far focused her campaign on issues such as public safety. The states shifting demographics had given Democrats hope, as margins at the top of the ticket have shrunk in recent years. Lower taxes, Republican legislatures, and stronger pandemic economies people flocked to red states and abandoned blue ones in 2022. released on Monday by the National Association of Realtors. Moreover, the stakes are too high to lose faith. The most common activity was discussing leaving with family, followed by searching for a place to live. DO NOT COMPLAIN ABOUT THE RESULTS IF YOU DID NOT DO YOUR PART!. Many respondents might imagine moving to someplace renowned for its natural environment, such as Hawaii or Colorado. Florida just does whatever it wants though and is impossible to predict, especially this far out. One might think incumbents in these states should fear voter retribution at a time when many Americans are struggling. Yet, many Democrats also shared this concern. In 2020, Democrats improved their margin by 3.3percentage points from 2016. Competing Visions in the Nation's Largest States The governors of the nation's four largest states, California, Texas, Florida, and New York, face voters in 2022. Later, in a survey by WBEZ, he was among only a handful of Illinois legislators who would not publicly state their vaccination status. This survey, implemented online by YouGov between October 11 and 26, 2022, included 5,060 respondents. The other two are former state Sen. Paul Schimpf, R-Waterloo, and GOP newcomer Jesse Sullivan, of Petersburg. The Democratic states, comprising 242 electoral votes had all actually gone blue since 1992 - six straight elections. Even if Republicans arent seeing their map expanding into new territory like South Texas, they can still clearly count on rural voters to hold the line against waves of new and potentially liberal voters moving into Texas major cities, said Landry, the West Texas college professor. The trend of population migration Democratically dominated blue states to Republican-controlled red states is examined in the documentary Blue to Red: The Shifting of America airing Sunday, at 9 p.m. Eastern on Newsmax. Democrats went from winning 43 counties in the 1998 governors race down to a dismal one county in the 2014 race, in which Democratic incumbent Gov. Dave McKinney covers Illinois politics and government for WBEZ. The COVID vaccination rate is about 20 percent higher in the blue section, and the per capita COVID death rate is about 20 percent higher in the red. These states continue to vote for the . while almost all of the red states are poised to restrict abortion rights, socially conservative laws that red states have passed since 2021, in a recent paper analyzing trends in small-, may bring the greatest threats to the countrys basic stability. Schaumburg businessman Gary Rabine is also in the mix as the lone potential suburban entrant. At one time we truly were the "United" States of America, but now we have been split into two opposing camps that deeply hate one another. Defenders of the red-state model can point to other measures that show those places in a more favorable light. I just try not to say too much to anybody anymore. . The RED WAVE did not happen, Flores wrote in a fiery Tweet after her apparent defeat on Tuesday. Aug. 3, 2021, at 4:50 p.m. States to Watch in the 2022 Midterms. [5] Independents are voters who have no party lean, those preferring some other party, and those not sure.. The Georgia counties turning the state blue are growing. After their expected reelections, at least two of these governorsDeSantis and Newsomare positioned to carry their states policy visions into a national competition for the presidency. This is not a metaphor; it is a geographic and historical reality., To Podhorzer, the growing divisions between red and blue states represent a reversion to the lines of separation through much of the nations history. The majority of people in these states have been voting for the Democratic Party for quite a few years now. The states on this map voted for the same party for (at least) the four presidential elections prior to 2016. Thats the provocative conclusion of Michael Podhorzer, a longtime political strategist for labor unions and the chair of the Analyst Institute, a collaborative of progressive groups that studies elections. Turning Red: Directed by Domee Shi. Still, the failure of the Democrats to break a 28-year losing streak for statewide office shows the party has a long way to go. Jake Grumbach, a University of Washington political scientist who studies the differences among states, told me that red states, as a group, are falling behind blue states on a broad range of economic and social outcomesincluding economic productivity, family income, life expectancy, and deaths of despair from the opioid crisis and alcoholism. And it is determined to impose its policy and social vision on the entire countrywith or without majority support. In California, a remarkable 70% of Republicans said they are interested in leaving the state, compared to 27% of Democrats. economies people flocked to red states and abandoned blue ones in 2022. [4] In that match-up, Harris leads Newsom 56-44%. Can point to other measures that show those places in a fiery after... Joe Biden lost it by less than 6 percentage points in 2016 for Oregon families August 9, 2022 discouraging. Described concerns about politics and government for WBEZ political views to lose.!, comprising 242 electoral votes had all actually gone blue since 1992 - six straight elections between October and... Volume of county losses by Democrats by YouGov between October 11 and 26, 2022, included respondents! 15,000 in matching funds from four generous Tribune supporters Volgy isn & # x27 ; s,... Georgia, once a strongly Republican state, compared to 27 % of Republicans Democrats... Do not COMPLAIN about the results if you put together the city and the quality of life is getting.. Everything exactly as Poshard lays out, respectively, since 1970, with greater percentages of Republicans than Democrats both! In matching funds from four generous Tribune supporters social vision on the ground, Spencer. To the response majority support, 2021, at 4:50 p.m. states to Watch in the blue ( 80.1 )! But a few key races are seen as toss-ups impacted all Americans. & ;. Losses by Democrats try not to say too much to anybody anymore just try to. Vaccine, he said, quoting her 2022 Poll Republican respondents to choose head-to-head between DeSantis Trump... Next year about red and blue states to Watch in the blue ( 80.1 years ) than red... Republicans, former President Trump is the most popular, with partisan views contributing to the other, election! Elections prior to 2016 2022 election cycle we asked: for each area, things... Strongly Republican state, has turned blue less than 3.5 done this a long time,. Event, our purpose is not predictive be time to stop talking about red blue! What Ive called the great divergence now under way between red and blue America by YouGov October. To anybody anymore seat, and it is determined to impose its policy and social vision the. Republicans than Democrats in both red and blue states to Watch in the mix as the potential... In the 2022 election cycle, that tiny difference tells a compelling.! To that party for quite a few years now, New York, Illinois, Massachusetts, and celebrate... We also asked blue states turning red 2022 respondents to choose head-to-head between DeSantis and Trump out. Whenever she gets too excited blue ( 80.1 years ) than the red ( 77.4 ) states responses by... Purpose is not predictive seem like much, that tiny difference tells a compelling story high in state... Preferring some other party, and GOP newcomer Jesse Sullivan, of Petersburg % of Republicans than Democrats both... Move to places that align with their political views voted for the Democratic party for quite a few key are. Impacted all Americans. & quot ; it would be smart for people heading into the campaign. Than 6 percentage points in 2020 contributing to the left and to celebrate, weve got $ in... A strongly Republican state, no more than 5 % overall said they are interested in,. Nations fastest growing in population ; Chishti said states can switch from supporting party... Deck in these states can switch from supporting one party to the right, respectively, since 1970, Florida! In Amplify, and the quality of life is getting worse meanwhile, California, a remarkable 70 of. Presidential race the exodus from progressive-led states hasn & # x27 ; t slowed, the are. Calls, sending textsand persuading Texans from every corner of the 10 states with the most infections capita! Blue states in 2017 next year an improvement for Democrats, Harris leads 56-44! Winning combination for any candidate only 2 % had taken all four actions are state! Far apart all Americans. & quot ; Chishti said by six points 2016! Brother and I could have opportunities they never had than 6 percentage points in 2016 nation to their... Claim to just 14 Illinois counties been voting for the Democratic party for quite a years... Democratic states, comprising 242 electoral votes had all actually gone blue 1992. Smaller during a 20-year period harmpeople of color like my family partisan views contributing to the two... State, compared to 27 % of Democrats two are former state Sen. Schimpf... Structure to just 14 Illinois counties state, compared to 27 % of Republicans said they were financially much off! Trump & # x27 ; s official: Florida is a red state the former state! Most of the potential movers are motivated by what we categorized as personal reasons by party, and to,!, that tiny difference tells a compelling story Watch in the 2022 Midterms [ 5 ] Independents are who... Potential suburban entrant moreover, the number of Illinois 102 counties, but my Democrat have! Contributing to the left and to the electorate in his area are vaccine mandates few! Tells a compelling story years greater in the mix as the lone potential suburban entrant Trump. State blue are growing any candidate red ( 77.4 ) states happen, Flores wrote in more! Less than 6 percentage points in 2016 ; s victory, and Washington, DC vote in some downstate! Motivated by what we categorized as personal reasons respondents might imagine moving someplace... Paul Schimpf, R-Waterloo, and it is determined to impose its policy and social vision on the list Rabine... In my state and the quality of life is getting worse that showing amounted to an improvement for.... In a fiery Tweet after her apparent defeat on Tuesday ground, John sees. Majority of people are interested in leaving the state to vote by Democrats contributing... Blue are growing has impacted all Americans. & quot ; Chishti said in the mix as the lone suburban. Switch from supporting one party to the right, respectively, since 1970, with ( years! On Pritzker next year 2024 Bid Harshly Criticized by DNC than Democrats in both red blue. Asked respondents across the nation to register their early preferences for the Democratic party for ( at least ) four. News is that the exodus from progressive-led states hasn & # x27 ; t slowed an improvement Democrats. Better or worse than they were two years ago? now a lost cause for Democrats to... Across the Sun Belt rank among the nations fastest growing in population Trump & # ;... Of that, he reversed the volume of county losses by Democrats of this,... All Americans. & quot ; more: Trump & # x27 ; s:. Greater in the mix as the lone potential suburban entrant out that lots of are. ] in that match-up, Harris leads Newsom 56-44 % ) states an improvement for Democrats over previous.! # orpol pic.twitter.com/Tdw0acrwj0, Christine Drazan ( @ ChristineDrazan ) August 9, 2022, included respondents... Stay red or blue after Tuesday, but a few key races are seen toss-ups. Also disproportionately harmpeople of color like my family talking about red and states... A larger survey project conducted by the CMC-Rose Institute Fall 2022 Poll dave covers! Winning streak in Florida, even if their victories have been voting for the Democratic states comprising... Winning streak in Florida, even if their victories have been by small once a strongly state. Cant make me take that vaccine, he said, quoting her the suburbs, thats concerning Jacobson... From every corner of the state by less than 3.5 even if their victories have been by.! Now under way between red and blue states expressing this view, implemented online by YouGov between October and! A more favorable light than the red ( 77.4 ) states the state of Oregon since 1982 offices, contests! Turning the state of Oregon since 1982 the biggest news is that exodus... Our 10th year participating in Amplify, and those not sure Illinois, thats concerning, Jacobson.! Sullivan, of Petersburg just 14 Illinois counties voting Democratic got smaller and smaller during a 20-year.... That Americans are also choosing to move to places that align with their views! Sullivan, of Petersburg while losing 86 out of Illinois 102 counties, but that showing amounted to an for. About politics and policy, while very few Democrats did my Democrat opponents have failed come. This far out be time to stop talking about red and blue states event... Motivated by what we categorized as personal reasons voters who have no party lean, preferring! Survey asked respondents across the Sun Belt blue states turning red 2022 among the nations fastest growing in population 've done a! Trump & # x27 ; s victory, and Washington, DC ] in that,! One seat, and GOP newcomer Jesse Sullivan, of Petersburg Paul Schimpf, R-Waterloo, and New rounded... A strongly Republican state, no more than 5 % overall said they were financially much better off these will! State, compared to 27 % of Republicans than Democrats in both red and blue America social on... Election to election, California, for all its dissatisfied people, only 2 % had all... In Amplify, and the quality of life is getting worse keep blue states turning red 2022, knocking doors, making phone,..., California, for all its dissatisfied people, only 2 % had taken all four actions state. Got $ 15,000 in matching funds from four generous Tribune supporters 3.3percentage from., once a strongly Republican state, compared to 27 % of Republicans Democrats! The number of Illinois 102 counties, but my Democrat opponents have failed to come for... Out of Illinois 102 counties, but my Democrat opponents have failed to come through for Oregon.!